Customer Reviews

Submit a Review
  • 5 stars
    97
  • 4 stars
    0
  • 3 stars
    0
  • 2 stars
    0
  • 1 stars
    0

Natalie Crumrine
(97 ratings)
5 out of 5 based on 97 ratings.
97 user reviews.
testimonial quote

Natalie made a stressful situation so much easier! She was available for questions and didn't make us feel stupid for asking even the simplest ones. She kept all of our process local and that was greatly appreciated. She gave us great feedback to help our house sell quickly and worked quickly to get our offer in on another home. It was a pleasure and she is a fun person, too! I would recommend her to anyone.

Eric and Heather P | Home Seller & Home Buyer
September 16, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie was such a wonderful help with the purchase of my first home. She was super kind and very personable which made my experience enjoyable. She was always there to answer my questions and responded quickly, even with my third shift schedule. She was great to work with and highly recommend her!!! Thank you Natalie.

Ashley Prowant | Home Buyer
March 9, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie did a fantastic job with helping to sell my home!! She made the process go really smooth and she was very outgoing and so fun to work with. I will be using her again in the near future. 5 stars!!

Victoria Hart | Home Seller
March 6, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie was very professional. Any and all my questions and inquiries were answered in a timely manner. Definitely recommend her to anyone looking for a home.

Lance Huff | Home Buyer
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

I am very happy we chose Natalie to sell our house and would advise anyone looking to buy or sell to give her a call. She was always available to answer questions and give her thoughts on the process which led to a quick sale. Thanks again for everything!

Larry and Marilyn | Home Seller
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie was a Great agent. Always answered my calls an answered my questions. Always prompt. After getting my house sold she knew what i was looking for an found that house for me as well. I would highly recommend Natalie to anyone to be there agent. If an when i need to sell an buy again i will be using her .

Bo Broad | Home Seller & Home Buyer
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Easygoing, fun, and aggressive to contact when a deal is found. Will absolutely work with her again for Building my rental portfolio in the future.

Connor L | Home Buyer
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie made our home buying experience fast and easy! As first time home buyers we had no idea about anything when it came to buying a house but she answered all our questions and got us into the perfect home for our family quick and easy! She made our home buying experience so much fun. We highly recommend Natalie, and will be sending all our friends and family to her!

Anastacia and Isaac | Home Buyer
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie is an amazing realtor! She sold my home quickly and at a fair price. She let me know promptly each time the home was shown and was very helpful during the process when an offer was made. I cannot suggest a better realtor than Natalie!

Teresa B | Home Seller
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie was very in tune with the things we were looking for in a home, and was quick to bring to our attention. Very timely with appointments for showing. Knowledgeable on all the questions we had. Both property and legal questions. Fun and down to earth. A+

Rick and Jill Kidd
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Amazing realtor to work with! Hard working, very knowledgeable, dedicated, great at negotiating and fast! She gets the job done while making things easy on you. Always available if you need help! Highly recommend!

Alex T
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie is the best! She sticks by you even after you get the house. Would highly recommend her to anyone!

Boston and Nick
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie is the best! She sticks by you even after you get the house. Would highly recommend her to anyone!

Hunter M
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie was very personal! She worked extremely hard to find us a home we love! I couldn't have asked for a better realtor. Shes seriously the best! No matter what time we would text her she would respond. Shes very dedicated! Thanks for getting us our dream home!

Josh and Kayleana
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

We've really enjoyed the time we spent with Natalie. She is very easy to work with. She will go to bat for you and is very responsive. I would highly recommend Natalie for your next buy or sell of your home.

Ryan and Lacey
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Amazing realtor . She was a blast and had my back countless times ! I would recommend her to anyone ! I've recommended her to my family and some friends that will be looking to buy a home soon . Not just a realtor to me I've built an amazing friendship with this lady in the last two times Ive used her to buy a home. I also trust this lady with everything she has tons of knowledge! Natalie has the biggest heart of them all. She is absolutely amazing . She helped us every step of the way with buying our first home . She was there whenever we needed her late night questions she was there and most importantly any kind of concerns we had she was there helping us better understand . She has a great sense of humor also . Made the journey we had full of laughs and smiles . Natalie didn't just become our realtor she became a family friend .

Jordan W
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie was always there anytime I had a question or was unsure about something. Natalie always got the answer for me and was always on top of everything. The way I got treated was great, like I was her only client. I would recommend Natalie to anyone, she is the best.

Kevin R
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie is the best! So easy to work with and so informative! She kept us up to date on anything happening with our sale. And what a quick sale it was! She made the whole process so smooth and easy! Definitely the best in town!

Lauren and Matt
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

My husband and I recently purchased a home , we worked with Natalie and she made the whole process run smoothly. She was always available to answer questions and quick to find solutions if we had any problems arise. We would highly suggest her if you are looking for a realtor, she has a great deal of experience and knowledge of real estate. But most of all she is a real person and that is hard to find ! Five stars for this lady !

Paul and Tyra C
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie did a great job on selling our home and helping with the purchase of our new home. It was a fast and smooth process! She is highly recommended by us!

Josh and Tiff
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie was so great! She knew her stuff and was so on top of it! She helped us understand the whole process being first time home owners and was there to answer any question along the way! We are so thankful for her during this process!

Molly and Jeff
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie was quick to respond to my requests and would notify me promptly of homes that became available. She listened to what style I was looking for and helped me find a perfect home.

Phyllis
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie was a fantastic experience to work with and went over and above all of my expectations. I hope never to sell or buy again, but if so, Natalie would be who I would use as my realtor without any doubt.

Brent
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Where do I even start! Natalie is just simply amazing!! She will always have your answer whether she already knows it or she finds it!! Natalie knows her stuff and I would tell everyone to use her! We have really enjoyed our time with Natalie looking for our first home! We are so happy with everything she's done for us and continues to do! No only is she our realtor she's a friend! BEST REALTOR EVER!

Brenna and Matt
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Jordan & I are first time home buyers and could not be more satisfied with picking the perfect realtor! She listened and responded so quickly to all of our numerous questions 24/7 because we were confused most of the time! She is someone you can always rely on to answer you anytime of the day and if she does not know the answer to your question she will get it to you fast. Natalie was always straight up with us and I think that's the best thing to look for when trying to find the best realtor. She is so dedicated to her work. I could not thank Natalie enough for all she has done for Jordan and I. I recommend her to anyone buying or selling, she has become a life long friend of ours! She will always be our go to realtor in houses to come!

Kaitlyn
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

I couldn't of asked for a better, more personable agent. Natalie went above and beyond for us. She listened to all of our wants and needs while finding us the perfect home.

Vance and Kaylie
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie made the process simple and was available to answer questions at all times.. it was my pleasure to annoy her as much as possible and I will definitely recommend her to others.

Doug M
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

As first-time home buyers, my wife and I were very unsure of the steps to purchasing a house. From day one, Natalie was incredibly helpful, responsive, and understanding to our questions and our requests. She was available day or night and was quick to find us housing options within our budget and with the features we wanted. Natalie was also someone we felt had our best interests at heart. She was someone that would go to bat for us in negotiations, but was also honest and blunt with us when we needed it. Above all of that, Natalie was easy to work with because she was personable. We never felt pressured or uncomfortable working with her and found it very easy to be honest with her about what we wanted in a house. Overall, as first time home buyers, we could not have been happier with Natalie as our realtor. She found us our first home in just a matter of weeks and made the whole process quick and easy to understand.

Kyle
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

As first-time home buyers, my wife and I were very unsure of the steps to purchasing a house. From day one, Natalie was incredibly helpful, responsive, and understanding to our questions and our requests. She was available day or night and was quick to find us housing options within our budget and with the features we wanted. Natalie was also someone we felt had our best interests at heart. She was someone that would go to bat for us in negotiations, but was also honest and blunt with us when we needed it. Above all of that, Natalie was easy to work with because she was personable. We never felt pressured or uncomfortable working with her and found it very easy to be honest with her about what we wanted in a house. Overall, as first time home buyers, we could not have been happier with Natalie as our realtor. She found us our first home in just a matter of weeks and made the whole process quick and easy to understand.

Molly H
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Very very good Agent she's an awesome person to work with I would definitely recommend using her over anybody else love her personality and attention to detail she helped me get the home I was after she the best she knows what's she's doing. And very fun to work with . p.s thank you so much Natalie

Eddie
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie is a really great realtor. She knows her job very well and does a really good job at it!

Chevy D
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie it's the best in the business, I wouldn't use another realtor.

Andy D
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

I gave five stars because when someone is really dedicated to their job, and wants to be great at their job, it definitely shows. I knew Natalie was one of these people because of her responsiveness to all my questions and concerns throughout the whole process. Natalie is a very hard worker and I would recommend her to anyone.

David T
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

I absolutely love Natalie. She was very easy to reach and helped us with all of our questions. She's is not only an awesome agent but a fantastic person! Highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy a home.

Izak A
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie was amazing and an absolute joy to work with!! She knows a lot about the area and was able to provide valuable insight and advice, as I was looking for a home in, or around, the Findlay area that would be close to work!! Once she knew what I was looking for, she found the perfect home for me in a matter of days, I took her recommendation on an opening offer, and it was accepted a few hours later!! I can't say enough about Natalie and what she brings to the table in regards to her knowledge, hard work, attention to detail and dedication to each of her clients!! Simply put, in a world of Crystal Ave agents, go with Natalie; she's 100% Pheasant Run!!

Jon
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

First impression was great when we start working together was always fun and straight forward Communication was great never let me hanging ( love that) quick response!! When I needed to do paperwork was Easy to follow instructions no hassle at all the experience was great overall I was impressed how smooth everything when thank you Natalie!! I will work again with her for sure!!

Rogelio I
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Great service. Immediate follow up. Attention to detail.

Joe and Linda
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie is great and will go out on a limb for you. She treated us with kindness, and helped with everything along the way. We were left in the dark on a couple things ( not Natalie's fault ) about dates we could move into our home. She goes above and beyond on once you've moved in by giving a gift. She is very very kind, and is very funny, too!

Steffen and Mercedees
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie is very trustworthy and is very passionate about helping her clients and knows the business very well. She answered all our questions and took the fear and concern about selling our home out of the equation. If you are in need of the best realtor in the area, you need to trust Natalie to work for you and with you.

Kevin and Janine Kinnet
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Truthfully, less than 5 minutes response time. Regardless of how early or late it was, Natalie was always there for us. Professional answers and a great relationship is what I will tell my family and friends to expect from Natalie. I couldn't imagine finding a flaw in our experience, she backed us up when things got tricky and gave us a beautiful gift for our new home we will cherish forever. We've moved out of state but anyone we know in the Putnam and Hancock County area's already know who we recommend.

TJ and Ashley
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie did an excellent job for us. I would recommend her to anyone buying or selling their home.

Bill and Becky
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

After looking at many unsavory houses with me and some places that she wouldn't even go into, I finally found one that I liked! Natalie is so pleasant to work with and made my end of the process easy and relaxing.

Roger Flanders | Home Buyer
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie was amazing! She was always just a text away whenever I had any questions. She definitely made buying our first home a wonderful experience!! I will recommend her to everyone I know who's looking to buy a home!

Tabitha
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie was amazing to work with!! She kept us informed and communicated well through the whole process. She made the transaction smooth and easy! Ill definitely be recommending her to others.

Alicia and Nathan | Home Seller
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

I had a great deal of fun working with Natalie. She is very responsive to questions(even at 5 am). She is a great all around realtor. Natalies attitude and personality put you at ease through the process.

Rachel N
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie was great to work with! She helped me buy a 'for sale by owner home' from a very challenging seller. She was very thorough representing me and made sure all bases were covered and and at the same time always kept it real. I totally trusted her knowledge and would be happy to work with her again.

Linda
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

As a title agent, I appreciate the fact that Natalie always has everything prepared from her end for a closing. She has a great attitude and I always enjoy doing business with her.

Bret Spaeth
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie was incredible! I had my heart set on a home and she did everything she could to help me get it! I am so thankful she was my realtor!

Wylie H | Home Seller
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

First of all I gave Natalie 5 stars, not because she is a 5 star Realtor but because there wasn't an option for a 10 star rating! I've known Natalie for most my life and she continues to amaze me. Not only did I have her sell my house but she helped me find my home! She was always available to answer my questions, no matter how crazy some of them were. She's was very straight with her answers. If she didn't know she'd have an answer in a timely manner. Natalie was an absolute pleasure to work with! I couldn't imagine going through all I went through without her on my side! A Huge Thank You to such a wonderful Realtor! Highly recommend her to be the help you need to buy or sell! Natalie was absolutely wonderful to work with! She was very patient and helped me through every aspect of looking for and purchasing a house. I would recommend her to all who asks.

Rick Parker | Home Seller & Home Buyer
February 7, 2024
testimonial quote

Natalie is wonderful to work with and will do whatever she can to help you buy or sell a house! We originally reached out to Natalie when we were looking to buy a house for the first time. We were so impressed with her that we knew exactly who to call when we decided to relocate and needed to sell. She explained every step in the process since we had never bought or sold a house before. She was in constant communication with us while we were trying to sell our house. I would recommend Natalie to anyone looking to buy or sell!

No first name G
February 7, 2024

Share Your Experience

The experience you've had in working with me is important. Please take a few moments and share how your experience was so I can share it with others.

Review Submission Form
  • Markets:
  • 1 Stars2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars

Login to My Homefinder

Pixel